Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

I received a complaint today; would like opinions

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • I received a complaint today; would like opinions

    I received a phone call regarding a complaint from a sucky customer today, & I would like opinions.

    "Kim", the director of Visitor Parking/Community Relations is out of the office today & tomorrow, & so her assistant, "Melinda", took the complaint.

    There are 2 gates next to the booth I work in. Customers are supposed to drive up to the booth window & not the outside gate. The outside gate is used by public transportation vehicles dropping off handicapped passengers at the university. But...customers inevitable drive up to that gate. Some customers either 1) sit there, realize the gate is not going up, & drive up to the booth window, 2) drive up & back hoping the gate will automatically go up, 3) sit at the gate on their cell phone with the window rolled up looking straight ahead, or 4) honk their horn when the gate does not go up for them. This particular customer did # 4. The customer was driving a big car like a suburban or an explorer.

    The first time I heard the horn I did not know if it was that car or another car since there was traffic in the area. Then I heard that car honk. I opened the window & pointed down to where to drive up to. The customer drove up to the booth window. Here is what happened.

    me: "Hi, how may I help you?"
    customer (with an irrited voice since she had to drive up to the window)" I need to park"
    *At that point I was confused as to why anyone would drive up to the outside gate & honk their horn when they realized the gate would not go up. I would think you would drive up to the window if it would not go up.*
    me (with a confused look on my face): "I am confused as to why you drove up to that gate since I am inside here & not over there."
    Well...that was a big mistake. I will explain later.
    customer: "The last time I came here you let that gate up"
    me: "I'm so sorry, but everyone always has to drive up to this window first."

    She parked in the garage, & complained to the Parking office, which sent her to Visitor Parking/Community Relations, the dept. I report to.

    I get a phone call from "Nancy" at the Parking office asking me if there is a customer at the booth waiting to get in. I look up, & there is a customer at the outside gate. I tell "Nancy" there is no a customer at the window but at the outside gate, & that she needs to come to the window. "Nancy", who is irritated, says "No, she does not. I spoke to "Melinda", & she said you can open that gate." Ok, I'm confused. I was trained not to do that. So I call "Melinda" & ask her what is happening. She says to open the window & motion the customer to come to the window & that "we will talk later." Since she did not say anything else, I hung up the phone. I opened the window & "Melinda" immediately calls me back. I answer it, & she says "I did not want you to hang up the phone. I want to hear what you tell the customer." So I motion for the customer to come to the booth window. She tells me she is "Nancy's" sister, &she is here to see her. I say "I'm sorry, but could you please come over here next time." I am confused at that point. I get back to "Melinda", but she had already hung up.

    "Melinda" finally calls me & asks me if another customer arrived at the outside gate wanting to be let in. I told her several customers did that, & asked her which one was this regarding. She asked me if I dealt with a customer who said that I let her in the last time. Since I do not do that, I said "No, I do not let customer's in through that gate."

    Then she said the following
    • That what I said to that customer made her feel stupid

    *which was not my intention. I was confused as to why she was doing & the fact that she said that I raised the outside gate for her before*
    • The customer told her that I said "I'm in here, not over there."
    *That was part of the dialogue, but it was not the entire dialogue*
    • That what I said was rude


    I said "may I say something?", & she said (in an irritated voice) "fine, that's ok"

    I explained to her exactly what I said, that I was confused as to why the customer did what she did, why she said what she said regarding my opening the outside gate for her the first time she arrived, that I never meant to make her feel stupid, & that I had a confused look on my face.

    "Melinda" said "do you understand how that made the customer feel stupid?" I was confused at that point, but I said "yes" since there was nothing else I could say.

    I told "Melinda" "I apoligize for what happened, & I take responsibilty for my actions." I was still confused, but there was nothing else I could say.

    After I said that, she said "bottom line is you do not do that. That was rude. I have to notify "Kim", she will be mad."

    Well.. I made some changes after that, & I e-mailed "Kim" a heads up explaining what happened & apologizing for what happened since she told me she will be checking her e-mails at night.

    I spoke to my co-worker, who works from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m., about this, & she mentioned that a female customer driving a big car like a suburban or an explorer drove up to the outside gate a couple of weeks ago. She was speaking on her cell phone, & her window was rolled up. My co-worker waited to see if she would notice that the gate was not going up. She said she sat at that gate for a while, & did not roll down her window. She ended up raising that gate.

    I would like opinions regarding what happened.

  • #2
    Seems to me like a ticking off as punishment for a brain to mouth filter failure. Happens quite a bit unfortunately, but does seem a little excessive - perhaps a bad day?

    If the customer had been before, they ought to have known the procedure. But of course, as we all know, their whims are there to be catered to, and if they decide not to follow what they know is the correct method of getting parking, well you'd best fall in line.

    There's a reason you made her feel stupid you know...
    Last edited by MannersMakethMan; 01-15-2009, 11:17 PM. Reason: Can't spell...
    "I'll probably come round and steal the food out of your fridge later too, then run a key down the side of your car as I walk away from your house, which I've idly set ablaze" - Mil Millington

    Comment


    • #3
      I don't understand why Melinda was siding with the customer without even letting you explain your position. I find that to be rude, personally. Honestly, I don't see anything that you did that was wrong. Maybe if you'd said, "Generally, that's what people do here," in resonse to her "I need to park," that might've been rude.
      I hope Kim is more understanding than Melinda.
      whohatesshrimp?

      Comment


      • #4
        Thanks for the responses. I needed to vent. This entire situation was crazy.

        Comment


        • #5
          It sounds like there is much confusion about the gates!! Is there a sign at the first gate that tells the customers to come to the window? If there isn't one, there should be, and it's not your fault, so the superiors shouldn't be coming down on you because the customers are confused.They need it clearly displayed so that customers know where do go.

          Secondly, if you have been trained not to let the gate up, then don't let it up, and don't take any crap because somebody's sister is being snotty because she isn't getting special treatment.

          Finally, I don't think you were rude to the customer. First, she honked at you, not once, but twice. That, to me is exceptionally rude. You motioned her over, apologised for the confusion, and told her that she needed to come to the booth in the future. Nothing rude there. Hopefully Kim will realise that you are being unfairly treated because you wouldn't give Nancy's sister special treatment.

          Comment


          • #6
            Hey, stuff happens. Customers misunderstand and/or misinterpret things and take offense. This woman was already annoyed, so it increased the likelihood for her to take offense. She was picking a fight. Irritating, but that's the service industry.

            Melinda, on the other hand, is a power-hungry douche. Sounds like she got chewed out and deliberately passed along the joy since she works in an area that gives her superiority over other departments. I think the email was a good idea, best to document things as much as possible since it sounds like Melinda is rather petty and quick to judge. At the end of the day, there's not much you can do. Keep your eyes open for further trouble brewing, since either Melinda just was having a bad day or she has it out for you. It isn't worth losing your job over such a petty complaint. Good luck.
            A lion however, will only devour your corpse, whereas an SC is not sated until they have destroyed your soul. (Quote per infinitemonkies)

            Comment


            • #7
              I'm going to side with the customers opinion that you were rude on this instance.

              I keep hearing this phrase:
              Quoth snugglegirl05 View Post
              me (with a confused look on my face): "I am confused as to why you drove up to that gate since I am inside here & not over there."
              over and over in my head and no matter the spin I put on the tone, even a genuinely confused one, I can't make it not sound rude.

              Not knowing the full situation or the layout of the parking area if I were driving there for the first time and encountered someone that said this to me I'd be a bit miffed.

              Granted I would more than likely assume if the gate wasn't going up that I'm supposed to pay or something else, or that the parking area is closed.

              I'm actually curious as to what the purpose of a person coming to the window is? Do they have to pay to park? Are they supposed to sign in, or are you only supposed to let certain persons through the gate?

              Comment


              • #8
                I am confused and I do not like to apolgozie for things i believe I didn't do wrong so... my opinion is that I'm too drunk right now to give good advice...
                http://www.deezer.com/#music/album/100130
                Melody Gardot

                Comment


                • #9
                  I don't think you did anything wrong. But be sure to talk to your supervisor ("Kim", was it?) and tell your side of the story since obviously this person didn't share all the details.
                  Ridiculous 2009 Predictions: Evil Queen will beat Martha Stewart to death with a muffin pan. All hail Evil Queen! (Some things don't need elaboration.....) -- Jester

                  Ridiculous 2010 Predictions: Evil Queen, after escaping prison for last years prediction, goes out and waffle irons Rachel Ray to death. -- SG15Z

                  Ridiculous 2011 Prediction: Evil Queen will beat Gordon Ramsay over the head with a cast-iron skillet. -- FireHeart

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Quoth snugglegirl05
                    "I am confused as to why you drove up to that gate since I am inside here & not over there."
                    Quoth Melinda
                    * That what I said to that customer made her feel stupid

                    *which was not my intention. I was confused as to why she was doing & the fact that she said that I raised the outside gate for her before*
                    I can very easily see how your remark would be considered insulting, even if that isn't what you intended.

                    I personally wouldn't do much with this complaint if you've generally been polite. Brain-to-mouth filter failures happen.

                    Unless Kim thinks the same way Melinda does I wouldn't worry too much about this.
                    Knowledge is power. Power corrupts. Study hard. Be evil.

                    "I never said I wasn't a horrible person."--Me, almost daily

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      From reading your previous posts I think the parking situation where you work is the most screwed up situation I've heard of in a long time and is bound to lead to pissed off customers by its nature. Unfortunatley you are "the face" on the screwed up situation so the pissed off people blame you for it when they shouldn't.

                      I hope they dont make an issue of this situation. I think the email to Kim was a good idea!

                      Steve

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        sounds like typical cater-to-the-cs and blame the worker spinlessness

                        the customer didn't like being told no, so it's your fault

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          You were not wrong. Your boss melinda is. This bugs me alot. She has now given that SC more power. That SC knows she can complain and whine and get her way. I dont mind if she had a valid complaint, but hers was unfounded. Yet she go awa with it. That is why I STRICTLY follow policy. I make NO exceptions. That way if my emploer fires me at least I will collect unemployment and get a break from SCs.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            If she wants you to break training, don't do it unless you have it in writing from her that you can do so. That should sort the shit out.

                            They're trying to scapegoat you, and it would have happened without the comment that could have been taken badly.

                            Besides, I get the feeling that the customer didn't need any help from you to look daft.

                            Rapscallion

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              As Raps said... get it in writing. Ask Kim if there's a different policy for certain customers (i.e. Nancy's sister LOL). If not, then tell her that unless she gives you specific permission to go against policy for certain people, you will continue to follow the policy as outlined when you were first trained.

                              Something tells me Nancy just wanted to throw her weight around - she could have prevented her sister's suckiness by just telling her "suck it up and drive around to the window", but she compounded her sister's entitlement by complaining to your boss.

                              Either way, never ask a customer WHY they would do something when it's clear you need to do this. I agree with a previous poster - that was just brain to mouth filter failure, and a bit rude. Simply explain nicely that the gate is only for commercial transit vehicles and that you're not permitted to use it for people simply driving in to park.

                              I think perhaps a bit of assertiveness would serve you well in this job - your attitude (from this post anyway) is hesitant and uncertain - aggressive entitlement whores latch onto that with a vengeance, and they will chew you up and spit you out unless you stand up for yourself.
                              GK/Kara/Jester fangirl.

                              Comment

                              Working...